Re: [Banshee-List] [feature suggestion] library structure



On Mon, 2009-02-09 at 15:09 -0800, OliverH wrote:
> Hi everyone,
>         
>         This is my first posting, I hope that works the way I want it to.
>         
>         I would like to suggest a feature for the file system organization
> of
>         the music library. In Banshee 1.4.2 I see options for structuring my
>         folder hierarchie and file name. But there are only few
> possibilities.
>         Everyone has another way to structure his library. I prefer to
> organize
>         my music under
>         
>                 ~/Music/Genre/Artist - Album (Year)/Artist - Album -
> Tracknumber -
>         Title.mp3
>         
>         For example:
>         
>                 ~/Music/RnB/Rihanna - A Girl Like Me (2006)/Rihanna - A Girl
> Like Me -
>         01 - SOS.m3
>                 ~/Music/Soundtrack/Hans Zimmer & James Newton Howard - The
> Dark Knight
>         (2008) - 14 - A Dark Knight.mp3
>         
>         Inspired by the program Easytag which helps to edit mp3-tags and
> file
>         names I would like to suggest more liberty for the file system
>         organization of Banshee. In EasyTag you can rename the file and
>         directories with variables:
>         
>                 %a : artist
>                 %b : album
>                 %c : comment
>                 %d : disc number
>                 %e : encoded by
>                 %g : genre
>                 %i : ignored
>                 %l : number of tracks
>                 %n : track
>                 %o : original artist
>                 %p : composer
>                 %r : copyright
>                 %t : title
>                 %u : URL
>                 %y : year
>         
>         This is also used for filling the tags by scanning the file names
> and it
>         can be extended with constant characters. Why not using such a
> scheme
>         for Banshee's library. Everyone could easily use his preferred
> method.
>         For me this would be:
>         
>                 Music Library: 
>                         ~/Music
>                 File System Organization:
>                         Folder hierarchy: %g/%a - %b (%y)
>                         File name: %a - %b - %n - %t
>         

This is already implemented, but not exposed.
The /apps/banshee-1/library/folder_pattern and file_pattern keys do what
you want.

Personally, I don't think exposing as you've suggested in the main
Banshee UI is a great idea. %foo variables in the UI either require a
long, unwieldy list, or are completely magical - who knows whether %z is
a variable, and if so, what its contents are?

I think it would be useful to expose something equivalent somewhere in
the UI, but certainly without magical variable names.  Possibly
something more like the audio-profiles or smart playlist UI?  A
selection of the available variables which could be added to the library
template.

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part



[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]