Re: [Ekiga-list] Difference between 500 and 520 echoes

[Dima <dima minignu minidns net>]

>>>>>> Hi.
>>>>>>      Ekiga 3.2.7 at Debian/SID (powerpc).
>>>>>>
>>>>>>      When I call 500 at ekiga dot net, I hear silence,
>>>>>>      and in fact, the numbers at the bottom of a window show that
>>>>>>      no audio is received from the ekiga.net server. Video is ok,
>>>>>>      after 20 sec my cam is echoed to me back.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>      On the other hand, when I use the 520 at ekiga dot net,
>>>>>>      it returns call to me, and then audio is just fine.
>>>>>>      Other audio echo services (4444 at sip2sip dot info) work fine.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>      With Twinkle on the same machine the audio echo from 500 at ekiga is fine.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>      What can be the reason that with Ekiga I get no audio echo from 500 ?
>>>>>
>>>>> This is surely a bug.  Could you use in debian the ekiga version from
>>>>> experimental and tell if the problem persists?
>>>>
>>>> Hi, Eugen.
>>>>
>>>>     I have built ekiga-snapshot using your script. Exactly the same phenomena
>>>>     persists. It is Debian Sid on PowerPC-32bit (iBook G4). Maybe its
>>>>     endianness matters ?!
>>>
>>> It seems yes.  In the past, I used a macbook too.
>>>
>>> Please provide a log when calling 500 and does not work.  It never
>>> works, is that right?  Or sometimes yes, sometimes not?
>>
>> I will provide a log at night (currently I have no access).
>> The behaviour is consistent, i.e. it is always as I described above.
>>
>> Creating log is `ekiga-snapshot -d 4 2>  log' ?
>
> Yes.

Hi.
  My results are different from what did I initially reported (the location
  of the machine changed?). But nevertheless, here they are

This time I was sitting behind a router (another GNU/Linux box).

EKIGA-SNAPSHOT (20 Mar 2012) and Ekiga3.2.7 behave similarily
ALL DEBUG LOGS ARE FOR EKIGA-SNAPSHOT

1. When port forwarding is set as needed
   http://wiki.ekiga.org/index.php/Enable_port_forwarding_manually

   both 500 and 520 work. Debug logs for 500 were created.

2. When no port forwarding is done, the results surprised me:
    500 has video echo, but no audio echo (logs created).
    520 succeeds to call back (how?) and audio echo works! (logs
    created)

Debug logs can be downloaded from
http://minignu.minidns.net/ppc32_ekiga_dbg_logs.tar.xz

Thanks,
  Dima.