Re: [Ekiga-list] Timeout? Call out OK call in from Diamon unseen or broken

[ael <law_ence dev ntlworld com>]

Philippe Laliberte wrote:
> Damien Sandras wrote:
>> Le lundi 22 octobre 2007 �1:52 +0100, Philippe Laliberte a �it :
>>  
>>> ael wrote:    
>>>> P laliberte wrote:
>>>>        
>>>>> ael wrote:
>>>>>            
>>>>>> Philippe Laliberte wrote:
>>>>>>  
>>>>>>                
>>>>>>> Hello,
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> I am running into a little problem. I did dig into the wiki but
>>>>>>> to no
>>>>>>> avail.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Set-up:
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Fedora 7.
>>>>>>> kernel-2.6.22.9
>>>>>>> Firewall disabled. selinux disabled
>>>>>>> Ekiga 2.0.11
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Router Modem ADSL SpeedTouch 780
>>>>>>> Firewall disabled (once I get Ekiga working I'll test what I can
>>>>>>> close)
>>>>>>> VoIp turned off
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Modem routing Configuration
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Protocol    Port Range    Translate To ...    Trigger Protocol 
>>>>>>> Trigger Port   Any            5000 - 5100    5000 - 5100     
>>>>>>> -                               -
>>>>>>> UDP           3479 - 3479    3479 - 3479  
>>>>>>> UDP                         3479
>>>>>>> UDP           3478 - 3479    3478 - 3479  
>>>>>>> UDP                         3478
>>>>>>>                         
>>>>>> I can't quite decode the above. If you trigger on 3478 (UDP) and then
>>>>>> open 5000 -5100 (UDP) then it should be ok. I am not sure that is
>>>>>> what
>>>>>> you have above is it? I can't make out the first line ending in
>>>>>> 5000-5100: how does that relate to the two following lines?
>>>>>>
>>>>>> ael
>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>> ekiga-list mailing list
>>>>>> ekiga-list gnome org
>>>>>> http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
>>>>>>                   
>>>>> Just missing a cariage return
>>>>>
>>>>> Protocol    Port Range    Translate To ...    Trigger Protocol 
>>>>> Trigger
>>>>> Port   Any            5000 - 5100    5000 - 5100    -    -
>>>>> UDP           3479 - 3479    3479 - 3479    UDP   3479
>>>>> UDP           3478 - 3479    3478 - 3479    UDP   3478
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> What you mean is that I should just do :
>>>>>
>>>>> UDP         5000 - 5100    3479 - 3479    UDP   3479
>>>>> UDP         5100 - 5100    3478 - 3479    UDP   3478
>>>>>             
>>>> Looking at that again, why are you translating 3479 into 5000-5100? Or
>>>> am I misunderstanding the web interface (I assume)?
>>>>
>>>> Once you see a packet on 3478, then open 5000-5100. Do not translate
>>>> 3478 into 5000... if that is what the above means. 3478 and 3479 should
>>>> be (con) tracked properly by the router. It is just that it will block
>>>> 5000-5100 unless it is told otherwise.
>>>>
>>>> I have not encountered a SpeedTouch router so I may be misunderstanding
>>>> its configuration.
>>>>
>>>> ael
>>>>         
>>> The error is mine, late doing too many thing at the same time. You did
>>> understand it correctly the first time.
>>> UDP         5000 - 5100    5000 - 5100    UDP   3479
>>> UDP         5100 - 5100    5000 - 5100    UDP   3478
>>> I'll test it later this afternoon thanks.
>>>
>>>     
>>
>> Why 5100 - 5100 ?
>>
>>   
> 
> Well unconclusive:
> 
> UDP    5000 - 5100    5000 - 5100    UDP    3479
> UDP    5000 - 5100    5000 - 5100    UDP    3478
> 
> 
> Wizard, still in symetric NAT
> 
> Manual STUN: No sound on 500 ekiga net, no calls in from Diamoncard even
> after a fresh restart
> None: 500 ekiga net ok, no calls in from Diamoncard even after a fresh
> restart.
> 
> 
> Back to no trigger definition, same as above.
> 
> Back to TCP/UDP
> 
> Any    5000 - 5100    5000 - 5100    Any    3478
> Any    5000 - 5100    5000 - 5100    Any    3479
> 
> Wizard, still in symetric NAT
> 
> STUN: No sound on 500 ekiga net, Calls in from Diamoncard OK even after
> a while, after manual changes back and forth it does not work anymore
> 
> None: 500 ekiga net ok, no calls in from Diamoncard even after a fresh
> restart.
> 
> Back to no trigger definition, same as above.
> 
> Wireshark shows SIP activity for the 500 ekiga call but nothing coming
> in from Diamoncard.
> 
> Can all this working not working be related to a slowness from
> diamoncard or the router to react to changes? I am connected to
> eugw.ast.diamondcard.us. If I try to setup my VoIp on the modem, it
> never seems to register.
> 
> I'll go back to STUN (with trigger of the router) and shutdown Ekiga for
> an hour or so to see if when I come back It will work.

You have looked at
http://wiki.ekiga.org/index.php/Ekiga_behind_a_NAT_router ,
I assume?

ael