Re: MUST or SHOULD in window gravity?

["David Wheeler" <dwheeler ida org>]

Sasha_Vasko said:
> It has to be MUST since all that comes not from this specs, but instead
> from ICCCM.

If the ICCCM is wrong, then this spec should override the ICCCM.
The spec already says that it overrides the ICCCM & it does so in a few places.
It certainly seems odd for this spec to mandate frame decoration placement.

However, if it's the opinion of this group that a window manager MUST
place frame decorations this way (as stated by the ICCCM), then this
"will" should become "MUST".  That way the text is no longer ambiguous,
and it becomes consistent with the rest of the document (including this
section).


-- 

--- David A. Wheeler
    dwheeler ida org