First of all, thanks to all the developers and contributors for a great piece of software. I use RB as my only music player, and I like it alot. I have some pet peeves about the track browser GUI, though. 1) The browser works hierarchically (Artist->Album->Search) but this is not evident in the GUI. The Artist/Album lists are both flat lists, with similar sizes and everything. The search bar filters what is selected in them, but is placed higher, which might suggest to a new user that it filters the whole library upfront. 2) When the browser is closed there's no clue anywhere of the currently selected Artist/album, unless you look at the tracks. Even worse, the search bar is still visible and keeps filtering on the _hidden selection_. It's the dreaded "some invisible controls are silently affecting the behaviour of the visible ones" thingie that is just plain wrong (tm) usability-wise IMO. Simple suggestion: add a label status line over the tracks list to show the currently browsed album/artist. Move there the search bar to make it clear that it comes last and affects _that_ previous album/artist selection (see the attached mockups, not pixel-perfect but hey :) ) I think it makes the UI much clearer, the con is that we obviously lose one or two rows of vertical space. -- Elia Cogodi <eliacogodi tin it>
Attachment:
RBBrowse_mockup_open.jpg
Description: JPEG image
Attachment:
RBBrowse_mockup_close.png
Description: PNG image
