Re: [ #17000] Application received from Valentin David (me AT


Valentin has done a fair deal of work on the freedesktop-sdk that much
of the release team work depends upon. Some of said work was carried
as a direct request from us, and can be considered GNOME contribution.

To be frank and objective, I would give a +0.5. It's not that I don't
trust him or something, but he has a quite big direct contribution
waiting to be reviewed [1]. Had this request come a few months later,
it would have been a definite +1 from me.

There has been some misunderstanding regarding this request too,
confusing account creation and foundation membership. Still, I think
rejecting this request would give a bad signal.

Given how the situation turned out, +1 from me too.




Le lun. 18 nov. 2019 à 17:54, Javier Jardón <jjardon gnome org> a écrit :

Valentin Is relatively new in GNOME but it has done a lot of the low level stuff to make gnome-build-meta 
and another flatpak related stuff a reality. I can not trust anyone else more and he is a top notch 


On Tue, 19 Nov 2019, 01:50 Andrea Veri via RT, <membership-applications gnome org> wrote:

Dear Javier, Abderrahim,

The GNOME Membership Committee is about to process Valentin's
application to become a GNOME Foundation Member and therefore need some
feedback about the applicant and their work on GNOME, both past and present.

Remember that vouching for a contributor means you really think the applicant
is committed to GNOME and will carry on contributing in the future, and that
you trust the applicant and their work. If unsure about vouching or not, please
let us know why you don't feel comfortable enough in advocating this applicant.


The GNOME Foundation Membership Committee

This message was sent via Request Tracker.

This message was sent via Request Tracker.

[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]