Hello, Good work on the icons, they have class. Here are some thoughts... At 24x24, when placed on a panel (or in a menu), the sheet background looks like a mess. The white border of the icon gains undue importance while the grey of the white cells, grey of the grey cells, and grey of the cell separators all fade into one another and into the panel background. See attachment. Also the squareness of the overall icon makes it less recognizable than a square and round bump of the old icon. Perhaps making the dark grey row names cells smaller and ending the sheet sooner would help your chart 'poke out' to break up the square icon. cheers, adrian On Wed, 2006-12-13 at 14:22 -0200, Vinicius Depizzol wrote:
Following the new Gnome Icon Theme, Tango Desktop Project is creating[1] a lot of icons for applications that doesn't use the newer guidelines. I created Gnumeric icon according to the actual[2] and this is the result: - Graph on center: http://www.ingral.com.br/~vdepizzol/icons/apps/gnumeric/48x48/gnumeric.png - First row/col darker: http://www.ingral.com.br/~vdepizzol/icons/apps/gnumeric/scalable/gnumeric-test.png - Graph with default colors of Gnumeric: http://www.ingral.com.br/~vdepizzol/icons/apps/gnumeric/scalable/gnumeric-default-colors.png What do you think? Comments? [1] http://tango.freedesktop.org/Tango_Fridays [2] http://ftp.gnome.org/pub/GNOME/sources/gnumeric/gnumeric.png
Attachment:
Screenshot.png
Description: PNG image
