Re: [GnomeMeeting-list] Setup question



Hi Damien,

sorry for puzzling you ;-)

Am Donnerstag, 24. Februar 2005 23:12 schrieb Damien Sandras:
> Le jeu 24/02/2005 à 22:32, Rainer Dorsch a écrit :
> > Hi Damien,
> >
> > Am Donnerstag, 24. Februar 2005 21:27 schrieb Damien Sandras:
> > > > Call forwarding is still not working but the debug output looks more
> > > > promising. It contains:
> > > >
> > > > 2005/02/24 21:07:12.510 3:05:57.063         H225 Answer:88270c0 H323
> > > > Party name "h323:118 145 140 124 118 152 191 172" mapped to
> > > > "118 145 140 124 ip$118 152 191 172:1720
> > > >
> > > > which looks like gnomemeeting is trying to forward the call which it
> > > > received via the gateway to the gateway (118.152.191.172), instead of
> > > > may laptop (118.145.140.124).
> > > >
> > > > Is that a bug or did I setup it incorrectly?
> > >
> > > That's not a bug but a feature. You have configured GnomeMeeting to go
> > > through a gateway, so all calls are going through the gateway,
> > > including those that are forwarded. If you do not want taht, then
> > > disable the gateway setting when you forward calls.
> > >
> > > The gateway is just a way not to have to type it in the url. So doing
> > > h323:5001 gateway_ip or configuring the gateway to gateway_ip and
> > > calling h323:5001 is just the same.
> >
> > Ok, that sounds good. Switching forwarding off, does not work either.
> > Maybe I did configure the forward host incorrectly:
>
> I guess you mean switching "use gateway" off?

Correct.

>
> > rdorsch paddy:~$ gconftool-2
> > --get /apps/gnomemeeting/protocols/h323/call_forwarding/forward_host
> > 118.145.140.124
> > rdorsch paddy:~$
> >
> > What I get is
> >
> > 2005/02/24 22:21:19.299 4:20:03.852         H225 Answer:8886c48 H225
> > Sending call proceeding PDU
> > 2005/02/24 22:21:19.300 4:20:03.853         H225 Answer:8886c48 H225
> > Sending PDU: callProceeding
> > 2005/02/24 22:21:19.308 4:20:03.861         H225 Answer:8886c48 H225
> > Sending PDU: facility
> > 2005/02/24 22:21:19.310 4:20:03.863         H225 Answer:8886c48 H323
> > Clearing connection ip$[::ffff:118.152.191.172]:2675/159
> > reason=EndedByNoAccept 2005/02/24 22:21:19.310 4:20:03.863         H225
> > Answer:8886c48 H323    Call end reason for
> > ip$[::ffff:118.152.191.172]:2675/159 set to EndedByNoAccept
>
> I need the start of the debug output.

Appended.

>
> > When I do 5001 118 145 140 124, I get
> >
> > 005/02/24 22:19:07.707 4:17:52.260         H225 Answer:87d2f40 H245
> > Stopping MasterSlaveDetermination: state=Idle
> > 2005/02/24 22:19:07.708 4:17:52.261         H225 Answer:87d2f40 H245
> > Stopping TerminalCapabilitySet: state=Idle
> > 2005/02/24 22:19:07.708 4:17:52.261         H225 Answer:87d2f40 H225   
> > Set remote application name: "Cisco IOS 12.x    181/18"
> > 2005/02/24 22:19:07.708 4:17:52.261         H225 Answer:87d2f40 H225   
> > Set protocol version to 2 and implying H.245 version 3
> > 2005/02/24 22:19:07.709 4:17:52.262         H225 Answer:87d2f40 H225
> > Sending call proceeding PDU
> > 2005/02/24 22:19:07.710 4:17:52.263         H225 Answer:87d2f40 H225
> > Sending PDU: callProceeding
> > 2005/02/24 22:19:07.906 4:17:52.459         H225 Answer:87d2f40 H323   
> > Party name "h323:5001 118 145 140 124" mapped to
> > "5001 ip$118 145 140 124:1720 2005/02/24 22:19:07.908 4:17:52.461        
> > H225 Answer:87d2f40 H225 Sending PDU: facility
> > 2005/02/24 22:19:07.908 4:17:52.461         H225 Answer:87d2f40 H323
> > Clearing connection ip$[::ffff:118.152.191.172]:2655/157
> > reason=EndedByNoAccept
> >
> > Nothing arrives at the debug output of the gnomemeeting running on the
> > laptop.
> >
> > Do I need to setup a gatekeeper or can I forward directly to the
> > gnomemeeting on the laptop?
>
> Why are you calling 5001? It was just an example. Is there something
> connected to 5001?

That was just to understand if gnomemeeting needs an forward target of the 
form xxx yyy  I expected that 5001 was an example, but I would have hoped 
that I get an rejection from the A (your nomenclature below)

>
> Sorry but I'm a bit puzzled by your tests, what you are trying to
> achieve and what works and what doesn't.

I am a VOIP beginner...so not all things I try might make sense.

>
> Things seem however simple.
>
> You have 2 cases. Imagine that you have machine A and B, and gateway C.
> If you get a call from C to A and want to forward it to B through C
> then you simply put B as forward host, C as gateway, and enable "use
> gateway", or you use no gateway and use h323:B C as forward URL, you
> will do this on A.

That is not what I want to do.

>
> If you get a call from C to A and want to forward it to B, without using
> C, then you simply put B as forward host and that's all. You will do
> this on A.
>

That is what I want to achieve.

The log (I am surprised that there is no indication at all about the 
forward_host 118.145.140.124):

2005/02/24 23:27:35.760 5:26:20.313       H323 Listener:83340e8 H323TCP 
Started connection:  host=::ffff:118.152.191.172:3201, 
if=118.152.251.114:1720, handle=45
2005/02/24 23:27:35.761 5:26:20.314         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    
Started incoming call thread
2005/02/24 23:27:35.761 5:26:20.314         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    
Awaiting first PDU
2005/02/24 23:27:35.767 5:26:20.320         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    
Receiving PDU: setup
2005/02/24 23:27:35.767 5:26:20.320         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    
Incoming call, first PDU: callReference=164
2005/02/24 23:27:35.767 5:26:20.320         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: iLBC-13k3{sw} <1>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.768 5:26:20.321         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: MS-GSM{sw} <2>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.768 5:26:20.322         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: SpeexNarrow-15k{sw} <3>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.769 5:26:20.322         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: iLBC-15k2{sw} <4>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.769 5:26:20.322         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: GSM-06.10{sw} <5>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.769 5:26:20.323         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: SpeexNarrow-8k{sw} <6>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.770 5:26:20.323         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: G.726-32k{sw} <7>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.771 5:26:20.324         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: G.711-uLaw-64k <8>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.771 5:26:20.324         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: G.711-ALaw-64k <9>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.772 5:26:20.325         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: H.261-QCIF <10>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.772 5:26:20.325         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: H.261-CIF <11>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.772 5:26:20.325         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: UserInput/hookflash <12>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.773 5:26:20.326         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: UserInput/basicString <13>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.773 5:26:20.326         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: UserInput/dtmf <14>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.773 5:26:20.327         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Added 
capability: UserInput/RFC2833 <15>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.774 5:26:20.327         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: iLBC-13k3{sw} <1>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.775 5:26:20.328         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: MS-GSM{sw} <2>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.776 5:26:20.329         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: SpeexNarrow-15k{sw} <3>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.777 5:26:20.330         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: iLBC-15k2{sw} <4>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.777 5:26:20.330         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: GSM-06.10{sw} <5>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.777 5:26:20.331         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: SpeexNarrow-8k{sw} <6>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.778 5:26:20.331         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: G.726-32k{sw} <7>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.778 5:26:20.331         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: G.711-uLaw-64k <8>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.779 5:26:20.332         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: G.711-ALaw-64k <9>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.780 5:26:20.333         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: H.261-QCIF <10>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.780 5:26:20.334         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: H.261-CIF <11>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.781 5:26:20.334         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: UserInput/hookflash <12>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.781 5:26:20.334         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: UserInput/basicString <13>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.782 5:26:20.335         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: UserInput/dtmf <14>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.782 5:26:20.335         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Found 
capability: UserInput/RFC2833 <15>
2005/02/24 23:27:35.783 5:26:20.336         H225 Answer:88f15a8 RFC2833 
Handler created
2005/02/24 23:27:35.783 5:26:20.336         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    
Created new connection: ip$[::ffff:118.152.191.172]:3201/164
2005/02/24 23:27:35.783 5:26:20.337         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    
Handling PDU: Setup callRef=164
2005/02/24 23:27:35.784 5:26:20.337         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H245    
Stopping MasterSlaveDetermination: state=Idle
2005/02/24 23:27:35.785 5:26:20.338         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H245    
Stopping TerminalCapabilitySet: state=Idle
2005/02/24 23:27:35.785 5:26:20.338         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    Set 
remote application name: "Cisco IOS 12.x    181/18"
2005/02/24 23:27:35.785 5:26:20.339         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    Set 
protocol version to 2 and implying H.245 version 3
2005/02/24 23:27:35.786 5:26:20.339         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    
Sending call proceeding PDU
2005/02/24 23:27:35.788 5:26:20.341         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    
Sending PDU: callProceeding
2005/02/24 23:27:35.798 5:26:20.351         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    
Sending PDU: facility
2005/02/24 23:27:35.799 5:26:20.352         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    
Clearing connection ip$[::ffff:118.152.191.172]:3201/164 
reason=EndedByNoAccept
2005/02/24 23:27:35.800 5:26:20.353         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    Call 
end reason for ip$[::ffff:118.152.191.172]:3201/164 set to EndedByNoAccept
2005/02/24 23:27:35.800 5:26:20.353         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    
Sending release complete PDU: callRef=164
2005/02/24 23:27:35.802 5:26:20.355         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    
Sending PDU: releaseComplete
2005/02/24 23:27:35.803 5:26:20.356                H323 Cleaner H323    
Cleaning up connections
2005/02/24 23:27:35.805 5:26:20.358                H323 Cleaner H323    
Connection ip$[::ffff:118.152.191.172]:3201/164 closing: 
connectionState=NoConnectionActive
2005/02/24 23:27:35.806 5:26:20.359         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    
Application not accepting calls
2005/02/24 23:27:35.806 5:26:20.359                H323 Cleaner H245    
Stopping MasterSlaveDetermination: state=Idle
2005/02/24 23:27:35.807 5:26:20.360                H323 Cleaner H245    
Stopping TerminalCapabilitySet: state=Idle
2005/02/24 23:27:35.808 5:26:20.361                H323 Cleaner H323    
H323Transport::Close
2005/02/24 23:27:35.808 5:26:20.362         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H323    
Clearing connection ip$[::ffff:118.152.191.172]:3201/164 
reason=EndedByTransportFail
2005/02/24 23:27:35.809 5:26:20.362                H323 Cleaner H323    
H323Transport::CleanUpOnTermination for H225 Answer:88f15a8
2005/02/24 23:27:35.810 5:26:20.363         H225 Answer:88f15a8 H225    Signal 
channel stopped on first PDU.
2005/02/24 23:27:35.820 5:26:20.373                H323 Cleaner H323    
Connection ip$[::ffff:118.152.191.172]:3201/164 terminated.
2005/02/24 23:27:35.868 5:26:20.421                H323 Cleaner H323    
Connection ip$[::ffff:118.152.191.172]:3201/164 deleted.
2005/02/24 23:27:35.868 5:26:20.421                H323 Cleaner H323    
Cleaning up connections

Thanks,
Rainer

-- 
Rainer Dorsch
Alzentalstr. 28
D-71083 Herrenberg
07032-919495
Icq: 32550367



[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]