Re: Behavior of Minimizing Windows Violates Mental Model

[Allan Caeg <allancaeg ubuntu com>]

Adding GNOME Usability list to the thread

On Tue, Nov 16, 2010 at 12:18 AM, Allan Caeg <allancaeg ubuntu com> wrote:

I like OS X's approach, where minimized windows are sucked into the dock with the "genie effect" then it will have it's own icon there (screenshot). This way, minimized and maximized windows are differentiated and you know where to find them. 

Here's a wireframe--> http://img715.imageshack.us/img715/2829/minimizem.png . This solution will only work for overview-relayout, though. We have to think of something that would fit the master branch's Activities Overview.

On Mon, Nov 15, 2010 at 11:24 PM, Allan Caeg <allancaeg ubuntu com> wrote:

Hello,

Just wanted to share a personal experience with GNOME Shell. One of its new and unique attributes is not having the window list or any sort of persistent widget that shows running apps or opened windows. This has benefits, in theory, like helping the user focus on the foreground task. 

It's just worth noting that one of its potential downsides is it violates the user's mental model, which makes it undesirable, even if it *may* help increase productivity. With a window list, it's clear to the user where the window goes when it's minimized and how to show it again. In GNOME Shell, the only clear way to tell if a window is minimized is to check if it can't be seen in the workspace, but it's shown in the Overview or Window Switcher (alt+tab). Teling which windows are minimized or not may not have real benefits, but it may be too disorienting for users.

--
Regards,
Allan

User Experience Designer
http://www.google.com/profiles/allancaeg#about
+63 918 948 2520

--
Regards,
Allan

User Experience Designer
http://www.google.com/profiles/allancaeg#about
+63 918 948 2520

-- 
Regards,
Allan

User Experience Designer
http://www.google.com/profiles/allancaeg#about
+63 918 948 2520