RE: GMC Network - (Long)
- From: "Fox, Kevin M" <kmfox bhi010 bhi-erc com>
- To: "'Jorge Gomes Silva'" <jgs plurimarketing pt>, "'Bobo Rajec'" <bobo bspc sk>
- Cc: "'gnome-list gnome org'" <gnome-list gnome org>
- Subject: RE: GMC Network - (Long)
- Date: Tue, 29 Dec 1998 08:21:46 -0800
1, the number of subnets/switches you use breaks down the traffic, and
2, If this is all going on anyway, "which it is on windows networks" why not
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Jorge Gomes Silva [SMTP:firstname.lastname@example.org]
> Sent: Tuesday, December 29, 1998 5:41 AM
> To: 'Bobo Rajec'
> Subject: RE: GMC Network - (Long)
> [OFF TOPIC]
> Probably this is not the right place for this topic but since it started
> here and since it may be interesting to help understand Windows networks
> I'm posting this here.
> => Network Browsing in TCP/IP Windows Networks <=
> There are 3 important roles when it comes to browsing a Windows Network:
> "Domain Master Browser"
> "Master Browser"
> "Backup Browser"
> The following is a transcript (I removed some parts of the text and
> included what I think it is the essential) from technet with my comments
> between :
> *** Domain Master Browser ***
> The domain master browser is responsible for collecting announcements for
> the entire domain, including any network segments, and for providing a
> of domain resources to master browsers. The domain master browser is
> the primary domain controller (PDC) of a domain.
> For a domain that uses TCP/IP and spans more than one subnetwork, each
> subnetwork functions as an independent browsing entity with its own master
> browser and backup browsers.
> When a domain spans multiple subnetworks, the master browser of each
> subnetwork announces itself as the master browser to the domain master
> browser, using a directed [note: "directed"] MasterBrowserAnnouncement
> datagram. The domain master browser then sends a remote NetServerEnum API
> call to each master browser, to collect each subnetwork's list of servers.
> The domain master browser merges the server list from each subnetwork
> master browser with its own server list, forming the browse list for the
> domain. This process is repeated every 15 minutes to ensure that the
> master browser has a complete browse list of all the servers in the
> The master browser on each subnetwork also sends a remote NetServerEnum
> call to the domain master browser to obtain the complete browse list for
> the domain. This browse list is available to browser clients on the
> *** Master Browser ***
> The master browser is responsible for collecting the information necessary
> to create and maintain the browse list. The browse list includes all
> servers in the master browser's domain or workgroup, and the list of all
> domains on the network.
> Individual servers announce their presence to the master browser by
> a directed [note: "directed"] datagram called a server announcement to the
> domain or workgroup master browser. Computers running Windows NT Server,
> Windows NT Workstation, Windows for Workgroups, Windows 95, or LAN Manager
> send server announcements. When the master browser receives a server
> announcement from a computer, it adds that computer to the browse list.
> *** Backup Browser ***
> The backup browser receives a copy of the network-resource browse list
> the master browser and distributes the list upon request to computers in
> the domain or workgroup [i.e. when some Windows user clicks the "Network
> Neighborhood icon"].
> Backup browsers call the master browser every 15 minutes to get the latest
> copy of the browse list and a list of domains. Each backup browser caches
> these lists and returns the list of servers to any clients that send a
> remote NetServerEnum API call to the backup browser. [i.e. when some
> Windows user clicks the "Network Neighborhood icon"]
> End of transcript.
> I won't go into browser election.
> How do clients know which computers are the browsers ? WINS. How does it
> work ? Browsers register specific names in the WINS Server where the last
> (16th) character (byte) of name has a special meaning. Two examples:
> <Domain Name><1B> - "Domain master browser name. This name identifies the
> primary domain controller and indicates which clients and other browsers
> use to contact the domain master browser. " (from technet);
> <Domain Name><1D> - "The master browser name that is used by clients to
> access the master browser. There is one master browser on a subnet." (from
> technet) [this is a list of addresses. Not only one address];
> When a client wants to get the computers in the network neighborhood it
> asks WINS for the master browser address, it gets a list of Backup
> from the master browser and it retrieves a list of servers from a select
> Backup Server.
> Conclusion: A client doesn't need to issue broadcasts to get the "Network
> Neighborhood". However depending on the type of node a Windows machine is
> configured as (node type is another concept. It defines in which way a
> computer will resolve a name to an IP address) it may be using broadcast
> resolve names to IP and only after that it will use WINS. In that case you
> have broadcast but it's not necessary.
> So, does this idea of WINS and browsers work well ? When you consider very
> large networks the answer is NO. In large networks the replication of WINS
> databases among WINS servers is a big pain. WINS management is horrible
> very unflexible.
> Sorry for the long mail. Don't flame me please.
> On Terca-feira, 29 de Dezembro de 1998 13:24, Bobo Rajec
> [SMTP:email@example.com] wrote:
> > [OFFTOPIC]
> > Thus spake Jorge Gomes Silva:
> > > Brandon S. Allbery [SMTP:firstname.lastname@example.org] wrote:
> > > > that a bunch of Windows boxes spamming the network every 30 seconds
> > > > noticed.
> > > You are wrong. That is true if you are running your Windows network
> > > NetBEUI. However if the network runs over TCP/IP (and this is what
> > > companies" usually have) you can use WINS.
> > He is right, unfortunately. You seem to be confusing announcement
> > broadcasts, aka browsing broadcasts, and name resolution traffic,
> > which could be either broadcasts or unicasts to the WINS server.
> > What you see in the Network Neighbourhood (NN) window is the result of
> > the browsing broadcasts. All windows machines produce these, unless
> > you specifically disabled it ("browser service") on the NT servers and
> > on all Windows machines.
> > I do not want to go into details like browser selections, master
> > browser, domain master browser and so on, it's all really crap.
> > You use WINS server when you want to connect to the specified NetBIOS
> > name. You could obtain this name from the NN window or you could type
> > it in manually (net use x: \\server\share). This is the case when the
> > windows machine asks the WINS server about the IP address of the
> > specified NetBIOS name.
> > That's why it happens so often that you see machines in the NN window
> > that really aren't on the network anymore ("Specified name could not
> > be found"), or you don't see nodes there when you are positively sure
> > they are there, up and running.
> > BTW: I've been on a large network with many servers and many pcs
> > coming up and down all day long where the browsing traffic accounted
> > for more than 60% of the broadcasts. It's *highly* recommended to
> > disable the service and leave it running on at most 5-10
> > machines. (bug: you cannot disable it in Wfw 3.11. Life is hard)
> > bobo rajec
> > --
> > FAQ: Frequently-Asked Questions at http://www.gnome.org/gnomefaq
> > To unsubscribe: mail email@example.com with
> > "unsubscribe" as the Subject.
> FAQ: Frequently-Asked Questions at http://www.gnome.org/gnomefaq
> To unsubscribe: mail firstname.lastname@example.org with
> "unsubscribe" as the Subject.
] [Thread Prev