[Glade-devel] RE : fill_empty method (was Helping out)

[e98cuenc free fr (Joaquin Cuenca Abela)]

Paolo wrote:
> On Sat, 2003-10-04 at 13:29, Joaquin Cuenca Abela wrote:
> > I'm also done with glade-widget-class, so please commit any pending 
> > changes.
>
> Attached there is a patch which turns fill_empty (the 
> function which takes care of filling the containers with 
> placeholders) into a method of GladeWidgetClass, since a 
> generic function, like the one we have now, doesn't work for 
> every widget. I made the patch some time ago and today I 
> updated it to the current cvs, but before committing I'd like 
> to hear your opinions on some issues.
>
> 1) For most of the containers fill_empty would simply do 
> gtk_container_add 
> (GTK_CONTAINER(widget->widget),glade_placeholder_new ()); so 
> I'd like to know which is the preferred way to handle this 
> common case. Among others I can at least think of 3 ways:
> - Every widget has its <FillEmptyFunction> (ugly)
> - Have a gtkcontainer.xml which declares the common 
> <FillEmptyFunction> and widgets inheriting from it can 
> override the method if needed (I don't know how to do it in practice)
> - Handle it in glade_widget_fill_empty() and only the widgets 
> which need something different have a not NULL fill_empty 
> method (this is what it is in the patch now)

I prefer the second option.  The less knowledge we defer to the .xml
files the best.
You can let it like you've done, and I will change it to the second
option if you have problems implementing it.
Just let me know.

> 2) Somewhat related to the above. Some widgets (e.g. 
> GtkButton) are containers, but do not have to be filled with 
> placeholders, this can be handled in two way:
> - adding more logic to glade_widget_fill_empty (like the current cvs
> works)
> - these widgets override the fill_empty method with the 
> ignore() function

Again, second option

> 3) With the attached patch applied [vh]box get wrong their 
> size (e.g 4 placeholders instead of 3). The bug can be 
> papered over be overriding the fill_empty method of [vh]box 
> with ignore(), but there seems to be something wrong in 
> glade_gtk_box_set_size... btw how do I set a gdb breakpoint 
> in glade_gtk_box_set_size now that it is in a shared library?

I didn't have any problem setting a breakpoint at
glade_gtk_box_set_size.  What's gdb complaining about?

> 4) In the patch I only included glade_gtk_dialog_fill_empty 
> and glade_gtk_paned_fill_empty; of course also other widgets 
> need to override the method. With regard to GtkPaned, is it 
> possible to create a gtkpaned.xml, put the 
> <FillEmptyFunction> there and have GtkVPaned and GtkHPaned 
> automagically inherit it or should both gtkhpaned.xml and 
> gtkvpaned.xml be created?

Just gtkpaned.xml should be enough.  Again, you should implement the
inheritability of FillEmptyFunction.
If you want to implement it yourself, take a look at
glade_widget_class_merge.  It's probably just a matter of adding:

        if (widget_class->fill_empty_function == NULL)
                widget_class->fill_empty_function =
parent_class->fill_empty_function;

Cheers,