[Evolution] Improve commit messages in Git repository



Dear Evolution folks,


I am bringing up the discussion in bug 682398 [1] on this list.


(In reply to comment #13 from Milan)

[â]

Regarding the explanation in the commit, I like the bug numbers being
clickable,

Milan, unfortunately that is not the case. Neither yet in the Web
interface nor will it ever be the case when using `git` on the command
line.

thus one can see whole story about the change, rather than
summarizing it to few sentences. I agree that bug reports can be sometimes long
and hard to read, but it's still the place where the change can be discussed.

Please look at it from the perspective of package maintainers. They are
(like you) already overloaded by work and have to keep up with dozens of
packages. You cannot expect them to know all the code bases and
understand all patches and to find out the implications.

Additionally please do not expect people to look at every commit and
then at every discussion in Bugzilla. The commit message is the place to
describe the problem with its implications, how it was introduced and
how it is fixed and what implications the fix has.

It would be awesome, if that policy for commits could be set up. (This
issue was discussed somewhere already, but again I cannot find the
report in GNOME Bugzilla or the message in the list archive. Matthew
acknowledge the problem and promised to improve that if I remember
correctly. :/)


Thanks,

Paul


[1] https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=682398#c13

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part



[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]