Hi, Thanks for the detailed report which permits to correct quickly the problem. Note that this bug was also valid for mp3 files containing empty fields. Here were attached two files to patch sources of EasyTAG 0.16 and 0.16.1. Sincerely, Jerome Thorsten Gunkel wrote: > > Easytag seems to dislike tagfields in ogg files that are mentioned in > the header but have no value. This is a problem for me because oggenc > creates such entries if you have something like oggenc --album "$album" > and "$album" is an empty string. I don't know if easytag needs to be > fixed to be able to deal with such entries or if oggenc shouldn't add > entries with no value (or if I have to check that I only use oggenc > options I have values for). > > This is how I can trigger problems: > 1. Create 3 wave files > 2. oggenc -q 5 --output="$ofilename" > --tracknum "$trcknr" > --title "$title" > --album "$album" > --artist "$artist" > "$ifilename" > With "$ofilename" is the destination, "$ifilename" the source and > everything else but "$title" is empty. > 3. ogginfo on one of the files > ,----[$ogginfo a.ogg] > | filename=a.ogg > | > | serial=1850893416 > | header_integrity=pass > | title=a > | artist= > | album= > | tracknumber= > | vendor=Xiphophorus libVorbis I 20011231 > | version=0 > | channels=2 > | rate=44100 > | bitrate_upper=none > | bitrate_nominal=160032 > | bitrate_lower=none > | stream_integrity=pass > | bitrate_average=169908 > | length=10.953651 > | playtime=0:10 > | stream_truncated=false > | > | total_length=10.953651 > | total_playtime=0:10 > `---- > 4. run easytag > - Enter something in the artist field. Switch to another file and back > to the changed one: The field is blank. > - Reenter something and apply the value to all files: None has been > changed. > - Reenter something and save the file: Change is not saved. > - Change the title and save the file: All empty fields are removed and > from now on all changes seem to work. > ,----[ $ogginfo a.ogg ] > | ogginfo a.ogg > | filename=a.ogg > | > | serial=1850893416 > | header_integrity=pass > | title=aa > | tracknumber=00 > | vendor=Xiphophorus libVorbis I 20011231 > | version=0 > | channels=2 > | rate=44100 > > | bitrate_upper=none > | bitrate_nominal=160032 > | bitrate_lower=none > | stream_integrity=pass > | bitrate_average=169895 > | length=10.953651 > | playtime=0:10 > | stream_truncated=false > | > | total_length=10.953651 > | total_playtime=0:10 > `---- > > regards > Thorsten > -- > There's a door > Where does it go? > It stays where it is, I think. > (Terry Pratchett, Eric) > > _______________________________________________ > Easytag-mailing mailing list > Easytag-mailing lists sourceforge net > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/easytag-mailing -- EasyTAG - Tag editor for MP3 and OGG files http://easytag.sourceforge.net -- Jerome COUDERC <j couderc ifrance com>
Attachment:
easytag_016_empty_field_fix.diff
Description: application/unknown-content-type-diff_auto_file
Attachment:
easytag_0161_empty_field_fix.diff
Description: application/unknown-content-type-diff_auto_file