Re: [Evolution] Reply for list messages should go back to the list

[Patrick O'Callaghan <poc usb ve>]

On Tue, 2010-07-13 at 23:10 +0100, David Woodhouse wrote:
> > I thought we were going the other way now, as you proposed I.e.
> turning
> > Reply To List into Reply To All when no list headers are detected.
>
> Remember, there are three different things which are affected...
>
> 1. For the *keystroke* (Ctrl-L): What's the point? If you mean
>    Ctrl-Shift-R, why not just press that instead?

Because that's not what I mean. I mean Ctrl-L and Shift-Ctrl-R is a
fallback, not the other way round. Every time I've replied to one of
your messages in this thread I've automatically hit Ctrl-L and it hasn't
worked, so I've had to pause and hit Shift-Ctrl-R. That's because you
aren't using the List-* headers, which I find very annoying since it
does work most of the time on this list. If Ctrl-L just worked I
wouldn't bother about it much.

> 2. For the *menu item* in the Message menu, it'd just be confusing. At
>    the moment there is already a 'Reply to All' menu item, and a
> 'Reply to List' item which may be greyed out. Turning the latter into
> a duplicate 'Reply to All' menu item would be wrong.

It wouldn't be a duplicate since it would have its own shortcut. In fact
it could even say Reply To List.

> 3. For the *button* in the toolbar, there isn't currently one for
>    'Reply to List' so we'd have to add one.

Add a Reply To List button if you like. I really don't care and I'm not
asking for it.

poc