Re: XML and GNOME community

["Anders W. Tell" <anderst toolsmiths se>]

Erik Andersen wrote:

> On Fri, 5 Jun 1998, Michael Zucchi wrote:
>
> >
> > Poor example.  Just re-configure the fire-wall to let it through, or
> > pipe it through a tunnel (yes, lets open a remote system
> > administration port to the whole world?  I dont think so ...).
> >
> > Either way, they are merely tcp connections, which is what firewalls
> > are designed to have fine control over ...
> >
> > XML might be ok for a clip board, or DnD, but does it have the
> > richness and performance and semantics for remote object
> > manipulations?
> >
> >  Z
>
> I am not advocating XML as the One True(tm) way of doing things.
> Personally, I couldn't care less if GNOME uses it or not. I was
> merely explaining one way XML could be used where using pure CORBA could
> be challenging.  Of course, this method would have problems too (such as
> writing an HTTP listener for the ORB).
>
> I think XML certainly has the needed richness and semantics since it is fully
> extensible and can utilize external scripting languages such as Javascript
> (ugh) or Scheme (more Gnome friendly).  I havn't any idea about performance,
> but it would certainly add in an extra parsing/interpreting layer that
> CORBA binary objects wouldn't have.

Even for Corba there exists a pack/unpack layers, using basically CDR.
1. between the client - commmunication layer
2. between communication layer and server.

Only in the case of "colocation" when client and server objects recide in the
same adress space
the marshaling is removed.

The CORBA pack/unpack however much faster since it is a binary mechanism.


> Whether it is the Right Thing(tm) or
> not... It certainly isn't a substitute for CORBA (as the original poster
> on this thread seemed to suggest), but for certain tasks (such as for a
> clipboard as you mention or for certain types of inter-process communication)
> it really is well suited.

I certainly didnt mean that XML is a replacement for Corba. XML is a "syntax"
standard and not a communication standard. However there is a small overlap
and that is between XML and CORBA IDL both meta standarder.


> But not well suited enough for _me_ to write
> stuff for it though [GRIN].  I already have plenty of projects on my plate.
> Punting to those that care...
>
>  -Erik
>
> --
> Erik B. Andersen   Web:    http://www.inconnect.com/~andersen/
>                    email:  andersee@debian.org
> --This message was written using 73% post-consumer electrons--
>
> --
>          To unsubscribe: mail gnome-list-request@gnome.org with
>                        "unsubscribe" as the Subject.