[Ekiga-list] ekiga for win32 does not detect NAT correctly

[Dieter Rogiest]

On Wednesday 14 March 2007 20:47, Julien Puydt wrote:
> Dieter Rogiest a écrit :
> > at my sister's place I installed ekiga for windows (2/3/2007) on WinXP.
> > She has a adsl router/modem Zyxel.
> > The configuration druid: detecting NAT: it always detects "symmetric nat"
> > no matter how many ports I forward from the router to the computer. Just
> > by chance I 've set the NAT traversal method to STUN (stun.ekiga.net) and
> > the echo test to 500 at ekiga.net works with echo of my voice.
> > The configuration druid still detects "symmetric nat" but video
> > conferencing is possible (although the sound is horrible, see my next
> > messages).
>
> Hmmm... which ports do you open & forward?

On her Zyxel router/modem I forwarded these ports to her computer:

Start port	End port	IP Address
All ports 	All ports	192.168.1.33	(for ultravnc)
5000		5100		192.168.1.33	ekiga,if NAT test reports"symmetric NAT" reports and
							no Linux then forward 5000-5100 udp ports
1720		1720		192.168.1.33	ekiga,H.323, to be reachable from the outside
30000	30010	192.168.1.33	ekiga, if you want calls with Netmeeting users

The first line states that all ports should be forwarded to her computer. So I 
guess the next lines are not necessary. 

Dieter